Modernising Antenatal Classes
Published: 12 August 2020
Published: 12 August 2020
Yet with many face-to-face hospital services in decline, is it time to ditch traditional antenatal education and implement a more dynamic form of parent-focused education (Gavin-Jones 2016)?
As research is beginning to suggest, many women are seeking far more than the traditional approach of a birth and parenting program attended in the final weeks of pregnancy (Svensson, Barclay and Cooke 2008). For some, the solution can be found by moving to the greater flexibility of interactive online education, but for others, nothing less than a complete overhaul of what is taught and how it’s taught is needed.
The aim of antenatal education has always been to prepare expectant parents to deal with pregnancy, childbirth and parenthood, with specific emphasis on topics such as pain relief and breastfeeding. Yet a recent Cochrane review concluded that the effect of antenatal education on childbirth, or parenthood, or both, still remains largely unknown (Brixval et al. 2014).
Some general themes do emerge from the research, however, even though many of the available research papers are now quite dated (Fabian, Radestad and Waldenstrom 2005). For example:
(Fabian, Radestad and Waldenstrom 2005)
Many studies into antenatal education suffered from weak research design such as poor descriptions of the interventions offered, or lack of detailed information about class sizes and specific content.
Fabian, Radestad and Waldenstrom (2005) suggest that it’s difficult to assess parents’ opinions about the value of hospital-based classes when they have often been exposed to so many other sources of information.
Ahldén et al. (2012) also observed that both expectant parents were keen to focus more on preparation for parenthood and infant care skills rather than on the birth itself. Lack of time spent on postnatal topics and adjusting to life with a new baby seemed to be a recurring concern, with some studies suggesting that a parent-infant support program would be more helpful for adjustment to parenthood than traditional childbirth education classes (Fabian, Radestad and Waldenstrom 2005).
One notable study exploring the most popular format for antenatal education recommended a range of strategies to be provided during the childbearing year, comparable to the presentation of a menu in a restaurant (Svensson, Barclay and Cooke 2008). This was based on three clear styles of program, each with essential components:
(Svensson, Barclay and Cooke 2008)
As self-responsibility for health takes on greater importance, the principles of adult learning become more important in antenatal care. Information transfer alone is no longer seen as sufficient, and according to Svensson, Barclay and Cooke (2008), a more flexible learning style should be embraced to allow parents to learn new skills and behaviours with maximum ease and effectiveness.
In other words, antenatal educators need to become facilitators rather than teachers and adopt more of an outcomes-based approach. Critically, this shifts the emphasis from the educator to the student and helps parents become life-long learners who are skilled in problem-solving and adapting to challenging life situations.
To complement the menu style of learning options, the method of learning used by parents is also considered important. This might include:
(Svensson, Barclay and Cooke 2008)
In practice not every hospital would need to provide all of these options. Instead, it would be a collaboration between hospital and community organisations.
Given the recent surge in online consultations and interactive apps, it’s perhaps no surprise that many providers are now looking at how to take aspects of antenatal education online. For example, a recent research study into a web-based breastfeeding education program proved very successful and may help to improve rates of sustained breastfeeding (Abuidhail, Mrayan and Jaradat 2019).
Conversely, Brixval et al. (2014) suggest that current evidence points to the importance of interacting with fellow learners in a conducive learning environment in order to obtain new competencies. In particular, small class sizes can help create an environment that enables expecting parents to discuss their feelings and concerns openly. Yet there is still very little high-quality research to support this theory.
As Bergström, Kieler and Waldenström (2009) note, antenatal education remains sensitive to opinions and trends and still represents considerable costs, yet it is poorly evaluated. With very broad and general aims such as preparation for childbirth and parenthood, clear outcomes are difficult to measure and high-quality research is scarce.
Traditional antenatal education has not been associated with particular benefits during childbirth, so as Artieta-Pinedo et al. (2010) suggest, future research should focus on redesigning and assessing antenatal education in the light of the current needs of both parents whilst also embracing the trend towards online learning.
Perhaps in the years to come antenatal education will undergo further review of how it can be delivered to offer maximum benefit to new parents. Online classes and a menu of learning options are certainly a possibility. Beyond that, some would argue that classes should also be designed and driven more by parental feedback, rather than on tradition alone.
Anne is a freelance lecturer and medical writer at Mind Body Ink. She is a former midwife and nurse teacher with over 25 years’ experience working in the fields of healthcare, stress management and medical hypnosis. Her background includes working as a hospital midwife, Critical Care nurse, lecturer in Neonatal Intensive Care, and as a Clinical Nurse Specialist for a company making life support equipment. Anne has also studied many forms of complementary medicine and has extensive experience in the field of clinical hypnosis. She has a special interest in integrating complementary medicine into conventional healthcare settings and is currently an Associate Tutor, lecturing in Health Coaching and Medical Hypnosis at Exeter University in the UK. As a former Midwife, Anne has a natural passion for writing about fertility, pregnancy, birthing and baby care. Her recent publications include The Health Factor, Coach Yourself To Better Health and Positive Thinking For Kids. You can read more about her work at www.MindBodyInk.com. See Educator Profile